According to audit, tax and advisory services firm KPMG, South Africa‘s mining industry is at a cross-road – despite the government clearly stating that nationalisation is off the table – a number of regulatory uncertainties remain.

The firm points out that the future success of the mining industry requires certainty on these regulatory issues, taxation being one, which has once again been at the forefront of the debate as to whether the State (as custodian of our mineral rights) derives sufficient economic benefit in light of President Zuma‘s 2013 State of the Nation Address.

In his address, the President had requested the Minister of Finance to commission a study of current tax policies to ensure that there is an appropriate revenue base to support public spending, with part of this study evaluating the current mining royalties regime.

KMPG feels that mining companies and investors have reason to be concerned, even though the nationalisation debate seems to be off the table, as it would seem government intends to increase its share of tax collection from mining companies.

The President’s State of Nation Address is not the only reason for uncertainty in the mining tax regime. It is generally accepted that South Africa’s mining tax regime is archaic, complex and out of touch with current economic realities, whilst special rules apply to encourage investment in gold mines and the investment of new mining capex, there are a number of areas which the tax regime has just not kept pace with, for instance, the tax treatment of open-pit mining or black economic empowerment transactions required in terms of the Mining Charter.

“More concerning is the South African Revenue Services‘ aggressive approach against mining companies whereby previously accepted mining tax treatments of certain positions are now being challenged, include methods by which deductions for capital expenditure and assessed losses are to be applied in the calculation of the taxable income of a mining company which owns and operates more than one mine as well as challenging the deductibility of prospecting expenditure by prospecting operators,” stated KPMG in a report.

The firm said that it awaited the full delivery of the 2013 Budget Speech which should touch on taxation in the mining industry, followed by a report.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy