Whatever the outcome of continuing talks between Amcu and the mine bosses, both parties will face survival in a drastically altered sector, say analysts.

The CEOs of SA’s three biggest platinum producers are meeting with the leadership of the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union (Amcu) this week in an effort to reach an agreement following a three-month strike that has crippled the sector.

Andrew Lane, Energy and Resources Leader at Deloitte Africa, believes the parties are likely to reach a settlement soon, although the repercussions of the strike will be felt for a long time.

“I think they might come to an agreement. Both parties must be feeling the strain.”

Mining companies put forward a revised offer last week, improving on previous offers of a 9% increase. Amcu members downed tools at Lonmin, Impala Platinum and Anglo Platinum in January demanding a basic salary of R12 500 over four years.

The latest offer would see the minimum cash remuneration (comprising basic wages and holiday, living out and other allowances) increase to R12 500 per month for entry-level underground employees by July 2017.

“To achieve this, the cash remuneration for these employees would rise between 7.5% and 10% across the various bands of employees, with relevant allowances rising in line with inflation,” a statement from the companies said.

Amcu leader Joseph Mathunjwa said last week that the union was not planning on calling off the strike, which would continue until the union’s demands were met. But the platinum producers have said that the increases are unsustainable, and would be catastrophic for business.

Even this latest offer is one the companies say they can ill afford, with both mining bosses and analysts predicting job cuts in future.

Dr Jacek Guzek, Deloitte associate director, said in a previous interview that the mining companies were actively looking into mechanisation and reduced dependency on a human workforce.

“It will be tough,” says Lane, predicting more cost cutting, potential layoffs and shaft closures at the mines.

“It will make the need for innovation that much more urgent.”

Feeling the squeeze

Lara Smith, Managing Director of Core Consultants, says the question of affordability is a big one.

“In 2006/2007, labour costs constituted around 40% of overall costs and now they constitute between 55% and 60%.”

She adds that as of last year, 59% of the platinum industry was loss-making at a price of $1600/Pt , with costs between 2007 and 2012 having risen 18% overall on a 4E ounce basis.

Smith notes that lower platinum yields have also affected productivity levels.

“Head grade has fallen around 40% since 2000, caused by a depletion of the Merensky Reef, which has led to mining on the UG2 reef which has a lower platinum yield. So, in effect, on a per kg per employee basis, productivity has declined by 38% while costs have risen.

“If this trend continues then we expect to see lower profitability, lower levels of investment and increased risk of mine closures,” says Smith.

Declines, divestments in future

Lane has a bleak outlook on the post-strike platinum sector, even if an agreement is ultimately reached. “I think output will continue to decline with huge pressure on costs and jobs.”

Smith agrees, saying strikes do not bode well for the economy as a whole.

“Ultimately, profitability, costs and wage increases need to be considered as a whole and what these prolonged strikes accomplish is merely to put managements’ backs up against the wall, forcing them to choose between a bad decision (give into increasingly higher wage demands) from a profitability standpoint, or a worse one (allow the strike to continue indefinitely).

“There seems to be a disconnect between job creation, wage inflation and job sustainability.”

As matters stand currently, Smith says one can expect to see continued disinvestment in the sector, ultimately leading to mine closures and job losses.

She adds, however, that if compromise can be established and the threshold for striking increased, as well as wage inflation being considered in the overall context of corporate and sector profitability, then there might be a reversal in this trend.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy