Brazilian miner Vale may consider suing the Guinean government after it cancelled the company’s iron ore licences last week.
The West African country scrapped mining rights worth billions of dollars jointly owned by Vale and BSG Resources (BSGR), following the findings of a corruption inquiry. BSG Resources, part of Israeli tycoon Beny Steinmetz’ empire, acquired rights to mine in the mineral-rich Simandou mountains in 2008, before selling a majority stake (51%) in its Guinea assets to Vale in 2010, forming joint venture VBG. Following a three-year inquiry into mining deals, the government of Guinea found that BSGR won its rights through corrupt practices, and withdrew the Simandou mining permits as well those in the Zogota mining concession area. BSGR has vehemently denied the claims, saying it would “prove these allegations are false” and seek international arbitration. In a press statement released in early April, the company said the Guinean government had employed “fabricated claims, compromised witnesses and illegal processes” to justify a “carefully orchestrated plan” by Guinean President Alpha Conde.The Technical Committee for the Review of Mining Titles and Agreements, which undertook the inquiry, did not find any involvement on Vale’s part in the fraudulent activity, and recommended that VBG, BSGR and its affiliates be barred from the reallocation of mining titles, but not Vale itself.
Vale had bought the stake in BSGR for R2.5 billion, but stopped payments after the first $500 million instalment because development targets had not been met. The Brazilian company put a hold on the project in 2012, and revealed in its 2013 annual report that it could lose its entire investment in Guinea pending the government’s decision. The Simandou mountains have some of the richest iron ore deposits in the world, with Rio Tinto developing deposits in the Southern part of the mountains. Vale said in a statement on Friday that it had acquired its interest in VBG after extensive due diligence, and on the basis that BSGR had obtained its mining rights lawfully. “Vale unequivocally condemns the use of corrupt practices, reiterates its commitment to transparent corporate governance and is actively considering its legal rights and options,” it said.