Does the platinum crisis sound the death knell of mining as we know it? As the platinum mining crisis enters its fifth month and continues to knock South Africa’s fragile economy, industry experts at a UCT Graduate School of Business (GSB) round table ask: what does it mean for the future of South African mining?

Longest, most expensive strike in SA history

The current platinum strike has been the longest and most expensive strike in South Africa’s mining history, with some 70 000 miners downing tools since 23 January 2014, costing mining firms R19 billion in lost revenue, miners approximately R8.8 billion in wages. In addition, South Africa’s GDP saw a drop of 0.6% in the first quarter.

But as platinum mining companies and union officials on the Rustenburg platinum belt continue to lock horns, with no resolution in sight, experts look to the future of mining, the bedrock of the South African economy.

Low costs, high productivity

What the future holds is an emphasis on keeping costs low and productivity high, said industry players at a UCT GSB roundtable discussion on 10 June. Opencast mines, which are low in investment but high in environmental impact, and mechanisation, lie ahead, a shift away from traditional labour-intensive shaft mining.

“Investors today want to get in, harvest what they can and get out,” said Peter Major, mining analyst at Cadiz Financial Services Group. Major, who holds an MBA from UCT GSB and began his career in mining at entry level, was one of four experts on the panel drawn from various areas of the industry to discuss the implications of the platinum crisis and the face of mining in the future.

A new reality

“Mining and mining plans must be made within a new reality,” said Michael Spicer, formerly CEO of Business Leadership South Africa and, prior to that, senior executive of Anglo American.

“To have sustainability, there has to be control of the costs and increased productivity. It as a different trajectory, a shift away from ageing, resource-depleted mines where metal is only to be had at deep and costly levels, towards shallow mines, a shorter lifespan and smaller, fleeter companies,” said Spicer.

6 150 abandoned mines in SA

With 6 150 abandoned mines on South African soil, labour, once seen by mining as a low-cost boon, is now regarded as South African mining’s biggest challenge, and one that mines are trying to reduce to stay alive, said Major.

It is not good news in a country where unemployment sits at 25%. What the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union (AMCU) officials are asking for is a raise of basic, entry-level salary to R12 500. Platinum mining companies, more than 50% of which were not making a profit even before the strike, said this has them over a barrel.

23% cost hike

“The AMCU demand, even if over four years, represents a 23% cost hike,” said Andile Sangqu, group executive: sustainability and risk, Impala Platinum, which is at the centre of the storm, together with fellow giants Anglo American Platinum and Lonmin.

“It is simply not affordable to us. With labour costs to the industry between 50% and 55%, it would be irresponsible to meet demands that are not offset by productivity improvements and project profitability,” he said.

Entry-level salary

Sangqu pointed out that the current entry-level underground employee salary is R5 500, well above similar sectors, where salaries start at R3 900. He added that the salary value was R9 297 once such factors as paid leave, living-out allowance, medical aid benefits and pension were included.

Sangqu, who had been informed by Impala in a call prior to the roundtable that a meeting on Tuesday morning with union officials had remained in deadlock, said the latest basic wage offer was R6 080, backdated to July 2013. A telephonic survey by Impala found that 85% of miners wanted to return to work, but feared retribution by intimidation and violence.

Latest challenge

The strike is the latest challenge to South Africa’s battered and once extremely profitable platinum industry. After 2008, South Africa, the world’s largest platinum producer, was hard-hit by the global recession and erosion of the market for platinum and its by-product, rhodium. Making a recovery, it has since been knocked by a surge in the scrap supply and the recycling of platinum by other producers, as well as by palladium, produced largely by Russia, and used as a platinum substitute catalyst, notably in the automotive industry.

Platinum itself is extremely labour-intensive to mine in deep shafts, and complex to process, yielding $135 worth per ton of rock, compared with gold, for example, which yields $220 worth per ton of rock. South Africa has 90% of the world’s platinum and supplies 57% of the market.

Marikana tragedy

Waves of strikes have also taken a toll, culminating in the August 2012 Marikana tragedy, in which 34 miners were killed in clashes with the SA Police Services, bringing the platinum crisis to the world’s front pages.

What mineworkers want, in addition to increased wages, in what is perceived as a very profitable industry, is better living conditions. The mines, which are still heavily dependent on a migrant labour system, in a bid to end the single-sex hostel accommodation, offered live-out subsidies, which has simply resulted, in most cases, in miners living in shanty towns.

150 000 migrant labourers

“There are 150 000 migrant labourers who have been drawn to the mines by work opportunities,” said John Capel, executive director, Bench Marks Foundation, a non-profit organisation that looks at the impact of mining, among other businesses, on employees and communities.

“Their basic needs must be met. We need a sustainable stock of housing, tarred roads, sanitation and lighting. One has to ask: what is the role of corporations, government and local government? I am dismayed government pulled out of the strike talks so quickly,” said Capel.  The government task team, set up by Mineral Resources Minister Ngoako Ramatlhodi, withdrew from platinum strike talks on Monday 9 June.

What is the answer?

What is the answer for workers, who feel that little has changed since the onset of democracy, and an industry under the whip? Opinions differ, but one thing everyone agrees on is that a solution needs to be reached and the strike stopped before it escalates.

“The platinum mining strike not only touches the heart of the South African economy, with mining playing a fundamental role in its health, but it also touches upon a myriad of social issues that need to be addressed, not only by mining, but by business and government ,” said GSB Associate Professor Mills Soko, who chaired the roundtable.  “A dispute such as this simply brings the issue to light,” he said.

Illiterate workforce

What has complicated the situation is a largely illiterate workforce. What is needed, suggested Major, is education. With a wave of uneducated labour, government needed to step in to “honour, protect and educate” its people.

There is no silver bullet, concluded Spicer: “We need to build consensus on the future that we want. The key is to talk to each other as people – it is a human issue. But if we do not have a proper conversation and act on it, there will not be a mining industry left to negotiate over.”

“Wherever we go from here, mining will never be the same again,” said Sangqu. “Whether mining firms are part of it or not, mechanisation and technology will come to the fore. We need to focus on improving the quality of lives and safety in the workplace. What is becoming clear is that we need a new definition of the role of business in South African society.”

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy