The Treasure Action Karoo Group (TKAG) is contesting a report by a Government task team into fracking in the Karoo, saying it is fundamentally flawed.

“It lacked representation from several Government departments, including tourism, transport, agriculture, health and rural land development,” TKAG director of operations, Jeanie Le Roux, tells Mining News.

“The report was insufficient and did not answer critical questions set out in the investigation,” she says.

Government to grant licences

On Monday, Government announced that it will be granting licences to approved entities for shale gas hydraulic fracturing, but this is being met with criticism by anti-fracking groups like TKAG and AfriForum.

“We had a meeting with the Department of Minerals (DMR) last Tuesday, which was a good opportunity to let them know what our position is. This is the first time this has happened in almost four years since we have been in the fight,” said Le Roux.

Econometrix report

TKAG presented its concerns to DMR, stating that the fracking report compiled by independent economic consultants Econometrix, including the report by the Government task team was flawed.

Le Roux says the Econometrix report was commissioned and paid for by Shell, who is one of the companies that have applied for exploration rights in the Karoo.

TKAG’s meeting with Government came less than two weeks after the group publicly petitioned President Jacob Zuma to reinstate the moratorium on fracking for shale gas, pending further scientific investigation and government action on other issues of concern.

Moratorium lifted

“Government still decided to lift the moratorium,” says Le Roux. “One of the big issues is public consultations. Government did not consult with people of South Africa. Many locals in the Karoo are unaware of fracking,” she says.

Government initially placed a ban on fracking in the Karoo semi-desert region of South Africa in 2011, but lifted the moratorium after 14 months.

Polluting groundwater

Le Roux says that there is a risk that the fracking process will pollute the natural groundwater in the Karoo, which almost 90% of people rely on in the region, adding that it is no longer just the Karoo that will be mined for shale gas, but also Limpopo, the Free State and KwaZulu-Natal Provinces.

“Our position under current situation is that it is not wise or best option to move ahead with shale gas mining,” says Le Roux.

The perceived economic incentive is what drives government on this, argues Le Roux.

‘Game changer’

TKAG believes that first prize for South Africa would be a transparent and scientifically valid approach to the investigation of shale gas resources.

“We maintain an open mind about the ability of shale gas mining to match the claims of its proponents – if it is indeed the ‘game changer’ claimed by Shell et al, then those claims can be validated by scientific investigation, and a thorough cost-benefit analysis in which science can inform policy,” states TKAG.

The non-profit environmentalist group, TKAG says that there is still work to be done on a number of fronts before shale gas exploration licences are issued.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy