A study into the standards of environmental assessment practitioners (EAPs) in the mining sector has revealed an ‘alarmingly high’ non-adherence to the government’s new Mining and Biodiversity Guideline (MBG).

The study by WWF South Africa (WWF-SA) scrutinised 62 mining applications submitted for mining in the Enkangala Grasslands and surrounding areas over a period of a year.

Vast prospecting area

Alarmingly, at least a third of the 1.6 million hectare WWF-SA Enkangala Grasslands project domain, across KwaZulu-Natal, Mpumalanga and the Free State, is currently subject to some form of prospecting or mining application, states the WWF-SA.

The findings are contained in a report commissioned by the WWF-SA and funded by the WWF Nedbank Green Trust entitled ‘Mining and Biodiversity: Evaluating EAP standards in the sector’.

Call for higher standards

The WWF-SA report calls for fast tracking the appointment of EAPASA (Environmental Assessment Practitioners Association of South Africa) as the registration authority for EAPs to ensure compliance and higher standards in the industry.

The wider grasslands domain is home to an abundance of wildlife and natural landscape and with the Engankala Grasslands specifically being a critical water source area, states WWF-SA.

Objective of study

The mining-biodiversity study’s objective was to analyse the mining applications for their adherence to the six core principles of the government endorsed MBG – as released in May 2013.

“The approximately 30% margin of non-adherence by EAPs to the MBG principles is too large to ignore and is cause for concern when considering the context of coal mining and its associated impacts,” the report said.

Disregarding environmental information

This confirmed what was already being experienced in practice, namely ‘that certain EAPs and/or mining houses are apparently disregarding critically important environmental information in the completion of their coal mining or prospecting applications’, states WWF-SA.

WWF-SA CEO Morné du Plessis says that environmental assessment practitioners play a critical role as they are meant to filter applications with acceptable impacts from those that would have unacceptable environmental impacts.

He says, “(They) then present their findings to the relevant authorities in an objective manner, thus promoting sustainable development in South Africa.”

Vital ecosystem services

Biodiversity priority areas are important for conserving biodiversity that supports the provision of ‘ecosystem services’ vital to people and economic activities, according to the MBG.

The WWF-SA report states that the failure to apply this biodiversity priority area principle results in major clashes between the biodiversity and mining sector. “It also carries major risk for the mining houses and can become a costly exercise for all parties involved,” the report said.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy