Anglo American Platinum (Amplats) and seven of its employees have initiated a legal battle against salary deductions for outstanding debt, which could have serious consequences for thousands of impoverished South African citizens and the way the debt is collected.

Amplats is challenging a law firm and an administration company involved in debt administration, under the allegation before the High Court in Pretoria that they are practising illegal overcharging.

Deductions of debt from salaries or wages at the source compel employers to deduct monies owed to creditors that have obtained judgments against debtors. This has been criticised because it for allows workers who can least afford to forgo their full wages to become indebted for long periods.

Amplats argues that the 12.5% fee charged by administrators, stipulated in the Magistrate’s Court Act, must apply also to attorneys doing administrator work. They cannot charge what they wish or circumvent the 12.5% cap by subcontracting their duties and adding that cost to the debt.

What subsequently happens is that the debtors’ right to dignity is compromised as they remain trapped in a poverty cycle. Chris Griffith, Amplats CEO argued in his affidavit that this could turn some heavily indebted people into “indentured labour, working to pay off administrators as well as creditors, often for indefinite periods”.

Hannatjie Pienaar, on the three respondents and representative of the law firm and administration  denied allegations that the companies charged an average 44% of the payments received from the seven Amplats employees. She stated that the charges stipulated in the workers’ affidavits were miscalculated.

Data in the Credit Bureau Monitor for the third quarter of last year showed 10.5-million South Africans had impaired credit records.

“The misuse of the credit industry and the legal regime with it can be the cause of frustration, social unrest and a denial of fundamental rights,” Griffith said, also adding that credit was useful in lifting people out of poverty but there were dangers inherent in the abuse of credit by those extending it and recovering it on behalf of creditors.

He outlined how it is common knowledge that the heavy indebtedness of the mining workforce may have played a part in the five-month strike for higher wages in the platinum industry last year and the violent events that culminated in the killing of 34 strikers by police near Lonmin’s Marikana mine in August 2013.

The National Credit Act and the Magistrate’s Court Act govern the formal repayment of debt and protection of debtors.

“Due to a possible lack of clarity in the statutes that govern their roles and lax regulation of their activities, exploit many of the heavily indebted people placed under their care” Griffith said.

 

 

 

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy