On Monday Ivanhoe Mines disputed accusations by journalists at one of Canada’s premier national newspapers, alleging that the company used illegal coercive tactics to obtain the necessary permits for its Platreef polymetallic mine near Mokopane, in Limpopo.

Open Letter
Ivanhoe management and its subsidiary, Ivanplats, released an open letter  to the The Globe and Mail’s editor of the Report on Business Paul Waldie and Africa correspondent Geoffrey York, arguing that the cover story was “blighted by false allegations and misrepresentations, and gratuitous exaggerations”.

Mentioned in the article are examples, one of which states,  two men, including an official from Ivanhoe, told an 82-year-old villager to give up her land or stand to lose her monthly pension of about $450/m.

“For the record, the company now does challenge and deny the allegation presented by The Globe concerning use of what would be an unacceptable negotiating tactic. It already is a matter of record that well-known Platreef critics have previously made similar allegations of pressure tactics as a ploy against other business entities, which also have been unfounded” the letter stated.

The story it was written that Ivanhoe used “hardball” tactics against the South African government when it announced that it wanted to initiate consultations on staffing with the labour unions, which would have included a review of alternatives to layoffs to conserve cash resources, while waiting on South Africa’s Department of Mineral Resources (DMR) to execute its mining permit.

Ivanplats pointed out that it had been providing the Platreef workforce with full pay even though the workers had not been able to work for four months because the mining right had not been activated. In the letter, the companies indicated that they had not been given the opportunity by The Globe to comment on this specific allegation before it was published.

The letter disputes the “hardball tactics” accusation, citing that South Africa’s mining law requires that companies also inform the relevant government department of intentions to initiate proceedings that could result in job losses. “There is no factual basis for The Globe’s mischaracterisation of the company’s conformance with this statutory process as an ultimatum to government.”

“…parts of the story serve as a soapbox for a coterie of dedicated critics, some of whose self-serving motivations curiously are ignored,” the companies expressed.

Project goes ahead
Ivanplats has indicated that “the project would not be held to ransom by those who advocate violence, intimidation, disruption and disinformation, and will remain uncompromised by corruption”.

In September Ivanhoe established a BEE deal, which gives 20 local communities a 26 percent interest in the $1.7-billion project, which paved the way for the DMR to execute a mining right for the Platreef project in November.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy