The president’s spokesperson Mac Maharaj has provided the key reasons for the referral of the Minerals and Petroleum Resources Development Act. Two weeks ago, President Jacob Zuma announced Act had been sent back to the assembly, citing only that it may not be constitutional.
Flaws within the actOn Monday Maharaj said “The …Act is likely (to be) unconstitutional in that the amended (bill) elevates the codes of good practice for the South African Minerals Industry and the Amended Broad-Based Socio-Economic Empowerment Charter for South African Mining and Minerals Industry to the status of national legislation.” These factors combined with the housing and living conditions of the minerals industry could be amended in terms of the legislation by the minister of mineral resources or even repealed. This said, the President detoured the constitutionally mandated procedures for the amendment of legislation. The effect of this would be to undermine the implementation of the government’s policy of broad-based black economic and social empowerment in the mining industry.
James Lorimer, the opposition mining spokesperson had argued that parts of the legislation appeared to be inconsistent with South Africa’s obligations under the World Trade Organisations General Agreement on Trade and Tariffs. The president appears to concur with this argument, saying the bill seems to impose “quantitative restrictions on exports” from South Africa.
In terms of the bill any person who intends to export “designated minerals” must obtain the mineral resources minister’s written consent prior to doing so. The President said this could render the state “vulnerable to challenges” in international forums. Webber Wenzel head of the mining regulatory group, Peter Leon, welcomed Zuma’s detailing of the reasons for his referral of the bill. “The fact that the president has serious reservations both about the bill’s procedural as well as its substantive defects should hopefully result in a better legislative outcome.”