On Thursday the mining industry was up in arms following Mines Minister Ngoako Ramatlhodi’s release of his department’s findings that indicated that the mining industry has fallen short of most of the targets of the 2014 Mining Charter.
The Chamber of Mines stated in a statement it had been agreed that the department would not release its ownership data just as yet. The subsequent release of the data was in contrary to this agreement reached in the last Mining Industry Growth Development and Employment Task Team (MIGDETT) meeting. Ramatlhodi said the department was talking to companies that had supposedly not met the charter requirements and would have to take steps to cancel mining licences under section 47 of the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act. According to the Minister only one-fifth of companies (weighted for the number of people employed) that had concluded empowerment transactions “fulfilled the full requirements of meaningful economic participation as inscribed in the charter”, Mr Ramatlhodi said. DisagreementIn the statement the Chamber indicates that the results presented by the Department of Mineral Resources (DMR) show both simple and employment weighted averages. The Chamber and its members emphasized that they do not agree with this DMR interpretation, which suggests that only 20% (on a weighted basis) of mining right holders have met the definition in terms of meaningful economic participation.
The Chamber said its own findings were that mining companies were fully in compliance with the Mining Charter’s ownership targets.
‘We have no option but to make sure that the correct facts, based on our interpretation are on the table. Based on independently completed research covering 85% of the value of the mining sector, the mining sector has achieved a weighted ownership target of 38.5%, which significantly exceeds the 26% targeted level and demonstrated meaningful economic participation by HDSAs,’ the Chamber said. ‘We note the differences in the DMR report which seeks to cast the industry as not having met its obligations. The DMR states that 90% of the companies achieved the 26% target on an employment weighted basis with an average of 32.5% HDSA ownership. However, the DMR in its own interpretation of meaningful economic participation is now of the view that mining companies have to not only do narrow based empowerment transactions, but have to also include community and employee ownership schemes, which they say on a weighted basis that only 20% of the transactions comply. The Chamber does not share this interpretation and is firmly of the view that 100% of Chamber members have achieved the 26% ownership target,’ the statement continues. The Mining CharterThe original mining charter was agreed among government, labour and industry in 2004 and meeting it is a requirement to retain mining licences. When compliance was reviewed in 2009, there was similar acrimony over definitions and whether or not targets were achieved. It was subsequently revised, setting higher targets.