…Continued
Glib reassurances
If one looks beyond the glib reassurances of the investor conferences to what party policy documents say and what ANC leaders say to their own constituency, the answer would most realistically be something between a massive state-owned mining company, or companies, and some private ownership with a larger or dominant black economic empowerment (BEE) ownership component. There is a great deal of ANC talk about increasing the state’s ownership of, and involvement in, mining. There are explicit calls for the state mining sector to be given regulatory advantages over private sector miners.
At the same time, the mining charter is due to be rewritten. A senior Department of Mineral Resources official has refused to deny that such a rewriting would include an increase in the percentage of BEE ownership required from its current 26 percent.
It is likely that the ANC is being both coy and obtuse about its aims, because it realises that the only place it can raise the large amounts of investment capital needed for a flourishing industry is the private sector. That investment would not be realised if the potential investors knew the industry would be one where its control was vested in the hands of the government and its BEE cronies. Therefore, the ANC needs to conceal its real intentions.
The government’s behaviour in presenting the MPRDA and its intention to rewrite the mining charter are clear evidence that the ANC has not changed its aims, and has only changed tactics. It is hoping for the frog in a boiling pot effect, that has the mining investors gradually growing used to less and less favourable circumstances, but settling for less and less return in order not to lose what they have already invested.
While not entirely incorrect, because market sentiment will always get used to new conditions, the ANC is also fundamentally misunderstanding capital markets. While they may be swayed by short-term circumstance and sentiment, the cold, hard calculations are inevitably done, and the value of a country as an investment destination, priced accordingly. So there will be no certainty, because it is not in the ANC’s interests for there to be certainty. It requires flexibility to keep continually changing. It is moving the goalposts, but is unwilling to let on to where.
Downward spiral
The mining industry has been squeezed to such an extent that the pips are squeaking. Bad legislation, badly implemented, in combination with the worldwide crash in the prices paid for minerals, has sent most of the industry into a downward spiral. Yet there is little sign the ANC realises that to halt the downward drift it needs to abandon its long-held vision for mining.