The South African government has released a new draft Mining Charter that radically changes targets and aims to firmly squash the contentious “once-empowered-always-empowered” principle.  Gazetted on Friday, the revised charter comes  a month after the start of a court case by the Chamber of Mines, seeking a declaratory order on the “once-empowered, always-empowered” clause in the version of the Mining Charter, which was finalised in 2010.

The interpretation of the contentious clause has been bogged down in dispute between the Department of Mineral Resources and the chamber.

The Chamber of Mines on Friday released a statement indicating that they had seen the new charter proposal for the first time this morning during a meeting with the Minister of Mineral Resources Mosebenzi Zwane.

It promised to use the proposal as “the basis for engagement between the [department of mineral resources] and key industry stakeholders”.

The major point of contention from the mining industry has been whether the existing charter obliges them to get new black partners if their old ones sold their shares or fell away for whatever reason.

A court application asking for clarity on this is making its way though the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria. The chamber said that the outcome of that case should influence the final version of the new charter. However, the new draft leaves no doubt that the minister wants mines to get new black economic empowerment (BEE) partners if they lost their old ones:

“Where a BEE partner or partners have exited, BEE contract has lapsed or the previous BEE partner has transferred shares to a non-BEE company, the mining right holder must within the three years transitional period from the date of publication of the charter review its empowerment credentials consistent with the amended 2016 mining charter,” the draft proposal writes.

Existing BEE structures that currently still reach the mandatory 26% black ownership target will subsequently have to change.

The proposal is that at least 5% of that 26% has to go to a worker share trust and at least another 5% must go to a community trust, effectively banning BEE deals that only benefit small numbers of black businesspeople. A traditional authority must be represented in each community trust and a union must be represented in each worker trust, the new draft continues.

The new proposed charter also introduces a scorecard system that is far more aligned to the country’s generic codes of good practice for empowerment. Each target will now be weighted and each mining right holder will get a score between 0 and 100. If a mine scores below 60 point, it will get sanctioned, the draft charter said.

The new proposed charter’s target for black representation at management level has increased significantly. The old target was 40% for all levels of management. Now it varies between 60% and 88% for the highest and lowest level respectively. Additionally, half of the black people should be women.
The existing charter set targets for local procurement from black companies. All of these targets are raised in the new draft. Now 60% instead of 40% of local capital goods must come from black suppliers. For consumables the target increased from 50% to 70%. For services the target has been hiked from 70% to 80%.

The new proposal adds a total ban on using foreign facilities to carry out tests on mineral samples.

Other changes include:

» A new Ministerial Skills Development Trust is created that will receive a portion of the 5% of payroll that every mine has to spend on specified skills initiatives;

» Expenditure on “community development” has to be at least 1% of turnover;

» The new charter calls for the minister of mineral resources to create the trusts into which multinational suppliers will have to pay 1% of their turnover from supplier local mines. The old charter said they should put 0.5% into “social funds” where the government was uninvolved;

» The 2010 charter had six overarching goals. The new one has five after “promote sustainable development and growth of the mining industry” got removed; and

» The 2010 charter said that the target of having BEE partners receive cash and take full ownership of their shares within the initially agreed time frame “subject to market conditions”. The new version removes this escape clause.
-News24

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy