Prof Tracy Humby from the Wits School of Law compared mine closure to a hangover: what is left after the party – and any subsequent after-parties – of mining. She said that the DEA had struck out on a bold path with the new regulations, and should be commended for this.

Prof Humby considered some of the tax complexities and implications for insurance products for mine closure and rehabilitation, and also spoke at length about the challenges of rehabilitation in the context of business rescue and insolvency – including in particular the terrible social costs that the lack of proper rehabilitation brings for affected communities.

A member of the Blyvooruitzicht community present in the audience spoke about his difficulties in getting the Department of Mineral Resources (DMR) to use the financial provision of approximately R34 million available to them to alleviate some of the dust and water pollution from the Blyvoor mining site, raising questions about DMR’s assessment of the adequacy of financial provision, and why these funds are apparently not being used by the DMR for their intended purpose.

Prof Humby described recent changes in the EIA and Financial Provision Regulations as a “wave of transparency” washing over the mining industry. These regulations now require mining companies to put their environmental authorisation, audits and financial provision on their websites, available for affected communities to see.

Prof Humby also spoke about the fact that South Africa doesn’t have a good model for deciding where not to mine, which causes major problems for closure in places where the environmental or social context should have prohibited mining from taking place at all. Fischer agreed that regulation through licensing was really just a way to mitigate the inevitable environmental and other damage. She argued for a more proactive approach of identifying where mining should not be allowed at all, and for better planning of the development of mineral resources. Prof Humby posed the possibility of doing a strategic environmental assessment to make an informed decision on where mining should and should not take place, such as was done for solar and wind energy and is underway for fracking.

Prof Humby spoke about the “myth” of mine closure, arguing that requiring restoration of land to a state similar to that is was in before mining was a denial of the reality that, even though mining is a temporary land use, it transforms the geology, ecology and society in the area.

Audience members spoke at length about the many challenges of mine closure, including:

  • The lack of uniform closure standards, linked to the DMR’s general unwillingness to issue closure certificates certifying that adequate rehabilitation has been conducted.
  • The lack of implementation by the DMR of the new rules, creating “uncertainty” exploited by mining companies. Many speakers argued that, if the DMR does not enforce the law, the decision to give the mandate of environmental management of mines to the DMR should be reversed. Others argued for greater resources to be made available to get the DMR to check the reports of audits of mines’ financial provision and take enforcement action.
  • How the lack of enforcement around rehabilitation undermines insurance products for closure – punitive measures for failures to rehabilitate are not perceived as a real risk.
  • The need for enforcement tools to go beyond criminal prosecution to meaningful monetary penalties.
  • The consequences of the failure to rehabilitate for the lives and health of mining affected communities.
The seminar was made possible by the Konrad Adenauer Foundation.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy