The long term planning practice of using commodity prices that are well above current spot prices is a dangerous tactic that aims to limit impairment charges in the hope that commodity prices will recover in the short-term, said Godknows Njowa, Senior Manager, Mining at Venmyn Deloitte.
It has resulted in companies mining at a loss, and even ceasing mining operations on mines for which they are still declaring mineral reserves.
“Any forecast used in the mineral reserves estimation should be below the current metal’s forecast spot price. The idea of using a lower commodity price compared to the forecast spot price is that the company should be seen as a going concern and to be able to continue economic mining operations, even during low commodity-price periods,” Njowa said.
Except for their ability to influence supply, “mining companies, in most cases, are commodity price takers and have little or no influence in determining the price of the commodities that they produce,” he explained. “Yet for mines, commodity prices are the single most sensitive input assumption in valuing the business.”
Forecasting long-term real commodity prices becomes one of the important economic inputs considered in annual mine planning, business budgeting and mineral reserves declaration processes. Unfortunately, the process of estimating commodity prices is given little guidance by international mineral reporting codes such as JORC, SAMREC, NI 43-101 or PERC Codes.
An exception to the lack of regulatory advice comes from the New York Securities Exchange (NYSE) regulator that has provided some guidelines on which commodity prices to utilise in the annual planning process.
Miners’ commodity price assumptions used in their mine planning and mineral resources declarations should be reviewed by the company’s board of directors together with other relevant and competent people while considering the potential influence on the Life of Mine (LoM) plan and financial statements.
“It is important to select an appropriate long-term real commodity price forecast so that the company does not react to short-term commodity price movements, but also to ensure that value is not destroyed by planning to mine at a loss,” he added.