The government seems to have been wanting to create the biggest shock possible in the mining industry with the newly released Mining Charter, which raises questions around the true agenda, says Soria Hay, BEE expert and Head of Corporate Finance at Bravura, an independent investment banking firm specialising in corporate finance and structured solutions.
The new Charter requires foreign mining equipment suppliers to pay 1% of their annual turnover, presumably only in South Africa, to the Mining Transformation and Development Agency. “This cost will most likely just be passed through to the mines,” says Hay. “Also, there is a lack of clarity on who runs this Agency, and how transparency and good corporate governance will be ensured.” The same Agency will also receive a further 2% of the Leviable Amount on skills development.
Finally, Hay highlights that the 30% BEE shareholding requirement is in fact a complete misnomer when it comes to the true distribution of funds; “The Mining Charter requires 1% of annual turnover to be paid to the BEE shareholders, prior to any distributions to any of its other shareholders, which again includes the BEE shareholders. For example, a mine may have turnover of R800 million, and profits of R40 million. R8m must be paid to the BEE shareholders before dividends are declared. Should 100% of the profits then be declared in dividends, a further R12m would go to the BEE shareholders, and R28m to “other” shareholders. The BEE shareholders have therefore received R20m, and the other shareholders R28m. This equates to a full 42% of profits going to BEE shareholders. However, it is important to understand that the investment to build the mine would have been funded proportionately to shareholding,” says Hay. “The other problem with this point is that low commodity prices, such as we have experienced over the last 4 to 5 years, have largely left mines either marginally profitable, or making a loss. However, the 1% of annual turnover that needs to be paid to the BEE shareholders does not depend on profitability.” The Mining Charter, already causing damage in the markets, is certainly revolutionary as promised, but not in a positive way, says Hay. “The Charter will certainly stifle further private sector investment, the last thing that the already challenged industry needs.”