The Saldanha Bay Municipality plans to accept all water that Kropz Elandsfontein (Kropz) will be removing from a 5 – 10 million year old Elandsfontein aquifer, on which it has established its controversial opencast phosphate mine.

The Municipality’s decision follows an earlier announcement by Kropz that it would delay – for an extended period – mining at Elandsfontein due to ‘’technical issues identified during commissioning.”

Carika van Zyl, chairperson of the West Coast Environmental Protection Association (WCEPA), which has opposed the mine due to the threat it poses to the eco-systems and livelihoods dependent on the Elandsfontein aquifer and the Langebaan Lagoon, said of the latest developments;

“We believe that at least two of the ‘technical issues’ Kropz refers to in its 15 August statement announcing the delay, are that the Saldanha Bay Municipality was unable to provide the 1.6 million liters per day it promised to the mine, and Kropz’s Water Use License (WUL) prohibited Kropz from removing water directly from the aquifer.

“Secondly, as expected by several water experts, the reinjection wells into the aquifer have been reported to not be working as well as planned.”

The new arrangement between the muniicapality and the mine will enable the municipality to provide water for industrial use, and water abstracted from the Elandsfontein mine as a ‘water service’ to effectively circumvent the prohibition in the WUL.

“The new arrangement will also solve the considerable problems for Kropz as they will be able to use the municipality’s water infrastructure as a convenient alternative to relay water extracted during the daily mine dewatering process,” continued Van Zyl.

Kropz has been attempting to artificially recharge the aquifer – at an injection rate never before successfully achieved in South Africa – with the water generated as a result of the dewatering.

Walter Anderson, Senior Associate at Cullinans & Associates, the law firm representing the WCEPA in its fight against Kropz, said, “It is notable and concerning that the Saldanha Bay Municipality’s resolution focuses almost exclusively on how the Western Cape droughts have affected industry, when one would expect drinking water and sustainable use of water resources to be the first priority.

“When an emergency situation like this presents itself we have to question whether water intensive industries like phosphate mining and processing are appropriate in perpetually water stressed environments such as the West Coast.”

Anderson explained that Kropz acted recklessly from the very beginning by establishing the mine without the necessary permits and contingencies.

He said since the water issues were only going to get worse in the province, and that the municipality should not have been complicit in allowing the mine to be established because it was not a sustainable option to go with from a water management perspective.

He added that the mine was not going to be a significant job creator, especially if it decided to close its doors every time there was a water shortage or dip in phosphate prices.

 

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy