The mining industry and its stakeholders cannot fault the revised Mining Charter lll and forget that the original mining charter was also flawed, these are the words of Hulme Scholes, the Director of Malan Scholes, a law firm specialising in mining & environmental dispute resolution.
The panellists noted that without forgetting the chaos created by the apartheid regime, the mining foundation had been successfully laid and the current mining ministry was destroying that foundation.
They noted that coming with legislation that contradicted Section 77 of the constitution would mean legislation would be converting the charter into a money bill. And that was unconstitutional. Jacinto Rocha, Director, Mineral Investment Advisory Services, added that if he were able to whisper into the minister’s ear, he would plead with the minister not to destroy what had been built over the years. “If we want to be successful in this so called radical economic transformation, we need institutional capacity. If you destroy that capacity, you shoot yourself in the foot,” said Rocha. “Don’t bring people into the mining industry who do not have experience or knowledge.” Rocha added, once stakeholders have dealt with the industry at an institutional level, then the industry could look at the regulatory framework. “If you look at the South African MPRDA and the Mining Act of Botswana, there is no difference. Botswana is praised for its mining industry and its mining legislation, because it is strict on conduct. When you want to change, you need to learn what you need to change; the minister must go,” he concluded.