Despite the increased outcry from environmentalists towards addressing the urgent threat of climate change – both in South Africa and abroad – the South African government has given controversial Thabametsi coal plant the green light.

South Africa’s own climate change response policy confirms that the country is extremely vulnerable to the impacts of climate change and that the energy sector is the largest contributor to South Africa’s greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and their climate change impacts.

With this in mind, environmentalists have rejected the proposed Thabametsi coal-fired power station in Lephalale, which is funded by Marubeni Corporation in Japan and KEPCO in South Korea, describing it as unsustainable in an era that will have to lessen its carbon footprint.

The coal-fired power station, was a preferred bidder project under the government’s Coal Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme, however it has yet to obtain further required licences and authorisations in order to reach financial and commercial close under the programme.

This appears to be on hold pending the finalisation of the Integrated Resource Plan for Electricity (IRP).

Makoma Lekalakala of ELA, which, together with the Centre for Environmental Rights (CER) and groundWork forms part of the Life After Coal/Impilo Ngaphandle Kwamalahle Campaign) said, “We are shocked that Minister Edna Molewa is allowing the project to go ahead when the climate change impact assessment clearly shows the devastating impacts that the power station will have, and despite South Africa’s international commitments to reduce GHG emissions.

“We need to take South Africa’s commitments to limit temperature increase to 1.5 or even 2 °C, seriously,” said Lekalakala.

According to Elana Greyling of ELA, the consulting group, EOH Coastal and Environmental Services’ (EOH) peer review of the coal plant confirms that the risks of harm are very high – pointing out that the climate change impact assessment should have classified the GHG emissions impact as “very high”, rather than “high”. She notes that the review goes on to say that “emissions risks are very high and water scarcity risks are high and … the very high GHG emission levels associated with the project implies a high social cost.”

Despite this, EOH claims that this does not necessarily present a fatal flaw, provided the benefits are justified and can be motivated.

This decision comes at a time when South Africa is revising its IRP and with a growing body of research from institutions such as Meridian Economics and the Council for Scientific and Industrial Research, showing that no new coal power capacity is needed in South Africa

Greyling added that government’s reason for allowing this project is that it would be aligned with the IRP 2010. She said however that to a reliance on an extremely-outdated document that is under review could never be a sufficient justification for a project that could cause irreversible damages to the air, water, and climate.

“South Africa’s electricity needs can be met – at least cost – with renewable energy, which does not have the climate, health, and water impacts of coal plants.

“The IRP 2010 does not reflect South Africa’s current electricity reality – the country currently has surplus electricity capacity and renewables are now much cheaper than coal-based electricity,” concluded Bobby Peek of groundwork.

ELA will be returning to the courts to challenge the government’s decision.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy