Africa’s civil society organisations in the mining sector should mobilise communities to force governments and companies to implement the Africa mining vision (AMV) in its fullest, including complying with human rights and environmental and safety standards.
This was one of the main recommendation from the Civil Society AMV conference hosted by the Southern Africa Resource Watch (SARW) together with its partners, the Third World Network Africa, Tax Justice Network, Publish What you Pay, The Zimbabwe Environmental Law Association and the Norwegian Church Aid from October 23 to 35 in Johannesburg. The meeting was also attended by the Africa Development Bank (AfDB), the Africa Mining Development Centre (AMDC), and UNDP. The conference was held to assess progress of the AMV in the past decade and to recommend a set of measures that will help increase visibility of the vision and its implementation by African governments. According to an Africa Union representative, Paul Msoma, 32 states in Africa are implementing various aspects of the AMV by incorporating it into their mining policies. The AMV adopted in February 2009 by the African Union Heads of State and government, is Africa’s overarching framework for achieving inclusive, sustainable mineral-based structural transformation on the continent. The conference was the second forum of the Civil Society Organizations CSOs on Africa’s mining vision. It followed up the conference, held in Zambia in 2014, that evaluated five years of the implementation of the AMV. The meeting recognized the AMV had made great stride since its adoption with the adoption of the action plan, the drafting of the Africa Mineral Governance Framework (AMGF) and Regional Economic Blocs, which are developing different instrument to promote its implementation. Despite this progress, the Director of SARW, Dr Claude Kabemba, says the AMV has so far not had “visible impact “on the lives of people in Africa, especially mining communities. The conference measured the AVM using the six pillars contained in the AMGF, which are the legal and institutional framework; fiscal and revenue management; linkages and diversification; artisanal and small-scale mining and environmental and social issues. Below are the recommendations for each pillar and the challenges that have been identified.
Meanwhile, for fiscal and revenue management, the recommendation was for model laws that help to strengthen capacity of Africa to fight illicit financial flows, corruption, and improve mining administration and management skills.
It was also necessary to put in place efficient and effective revenue capturing systems including taxation; distribution of revenue systems; transparency mechanisms that allows the public to participate; the ploughing of profits into community projects; transfer pricing policies and monitoring and harmonization of fiscal regime models. Tax Justice Network representative, Michael Otieno, says illicit financial flows and ensuring that resources remain on the continent are some of the major challenges. Silas Olang, who was speaking on behalf of NRGI, notes that there is a lot of discussion around revenue maximisation and not on optimisation. “Optimisation looks at the revenues that are due to government and how they will be managed. NRGI looks at testing fiscal regimes in the context of the extractives sector. How does it respond to the initial stages of the mining sector? How does the regime respond to cost scenarios, price changes?” An example is Zambia, which since 2008 has had seven changes in its fiscal regime on the taxes on production and taxes on profitability. In 2016, Zambia introduced a sliding royalty tax to get more revenue when copper prices were high. Olang notes that Africa missed a lot when the gold prices were skyrocketing because regimes in Africa were not flexible to accommodate the gold prices. He adds: “If your fiscal regimes are porous, they will not address tax avoidance and evasion”.