The much-anticipated influx of capital from new mining-focused private funds is taking longer than expected to hit the market, but market experts expect more deals to hit in the second half of 2014 and an increase in activity in early 2015.
Multinational professional services firm, Ernst & Young, estimates that mining-focused private capital funds have amassed at least $10 billion, and possibly as high as $20 billion, to invest in the global metals and mining sector. The firm’s global mining and metals transactions leader, Lee Downham, said mergers and acquisitions activity is likely to remain subdued for the rest of 2014 despite a strong deal pipeline and a private capital funds war chest yet to be unleashed.Capital discipline
“Dealmaking in the sector continues to be cautious, partly due to the continuing commitment to capital discipline, but also due to a lack of urgency over investment given the lack of competition for assets,” Downham said in a statement. “Some standout deals and hostile bids during Q2, combined with a strong deal pipeline and substantial capital waiting to be deployed by mining-focused funds, suggest that momentum is building.” While Ernst & Young’s year-over-year comparisons, which are based solely on completed deals, show a decline in deal volume and value in the first half of 2014, data compiled by SNL Metals & Mining that tracks announced deals indicates that the number and value of deals is on the rise.Decline in deals
Ernst & Young data shows total completed deal values for the first half down 69% year-over-year to $16.7 billion from $53.8 billion, with deal volumes down 34% to 254, from 386 in the first half of 2013. Meanwhile, according the first six months of 2014 saw 117 announced deals totalling $13.21 billion, a 70% increase on the 69 deals worth around $11.33 billion announced in the same period of 2013, according to SNL Metals & Metals analysts. Importantly, Ernst & Young’s figures include deals involving steel, with some $4.36 billion of transactions involving that commodity; SNL Metals & Mining data excludes such deals. The largest deal announced during the first half of 2014 was the $3.49 billion acquisition of Osisko Mining Corp by Yamana Gold and Agnico Eagle Mines, which helped drive up total deal value.Hostile takeovers
The gap between seller and buyer price expectations has been a factor in deals being delayed or not completed and even forcing hostile takeovers in some instances. The consensus among industry watchers is this will still remain an issue in the last half of 2014 and early 2015, perhaps even longer. While some believe the gap will be a factor in mining mergers and acquisitions (M&A) deals for some time, Ernst & Young expects it to narrow in the first half of 2015. Downham attributes the forecast reduction in the valuation gap to improving commodity prices and positive results from miners’ cost-reduction programs. “Instead of having to value on the promise of a cost-reduction program, you are able to value on the back of cost reductions that have come through on the income statement that you can see, and that again naturally helps to bridge that gap because you’ve got a lot more confidence in what your margins are,” he told SNL.Opportunities for private capital limited
The consensus is that the cash being accumulated by mining-focused private capital funds is pent up and there is a demand for private equity; however, the range of opportunities available to these types of investors is viewed as limited. According to industry experts, private capital funds are more inclined to seek out advanced assets in low-risk jurisdictions. PricewaterhouseCoopers Australia mining leader Jock O’Callaghan told SNL that private capital investors will likely have less of an appetite for investments in developing mining countries than other new investors and China will. “I think geographically they will have more appetite for stable jurisdictions and that will be a pretty critical factor in their investments,” O’Callaghan said. “There is also the issue of where in the asset lifecycle they would be prepared to put their money. I suspect that they will have much more difficulty investing their equity into projects that are not existing and producing mines.”High-risk assets buys
Ernst & Young’s Downham agrees that private capital buyers are most likely to steer clear of higher-risk asset buys. “They typically won’t do the high-risk deals in high-risk geographies because they don’t necessarily have the strength of blue chip corporate behind them that gives them some protection,” he told SNL. “So they will be a little bit more exposed to the very high-risk markets and therefore you may see them avoiding those.” However, advanced assets, where there is a reasonably high-degree of confidence in the resource that lies within the project, in low-risk locations are a lot harder to come by and much more expensive.Nigel Lake, joint CEO and founder of corporate advisory firm Pottinger, told SNL that if private capital buyers wanted to secure these types of resources, they would have to look at earlier stage, riskier assets and find ways to value those projects in the face of much more risk than they may otherwise have wanted to take on.
Corporates still key players in deals
Given the limited scope for private capital buyers, this is likely to mean that the majority of M&A activity expected in the last half of 2014, and early 2015 will still be led by corporates. PricewaterhouseCoopers’ O’Callaghan is not convinced that the market will be seeing a ‘wave’ of deals being done by private capital buyers. “I think we’ll see it in a more episodic rather than thematic way when the conditions are just right for a private equity buyer,” he said. “Comparing it to other industries, it’s not the sort of industry you can see will have a sizable portion of its ownership sitting in the hands of private equity.” Ernst & Young anticipates M&A activity will start to pick up in the first half of 2015. “We would hope to see deals being closed this year and increase in terms of regularity first half of next year, but you may find some that pull the trigger on a handful of deals very quickly and others that bide their time and take another year or so looking for the perfect deal,” Downham told SNL.Divestment by majors
Major diversifieds are continuing to consider divestments as a way of reducing debt, maximising returns on capital and optimising their portfolios, though stronger balance sheets have taken the urgency out of these deals. “We do, however, think divestments of noncore assets from the majors will pick up pace in the next six months,” Downham said. “While these assets may not be strategic to the divesting companies, they are typically high-quality assets and will likely attract strong competition, particularly from private capital buyers.” Acquisitions by financial investors accounted for 20% of all mining and metals deal volumes globally in the first half of 2014, according to Ernst & Young. Although M&A activity is expected to rise, the increase is not likely to be a dramatic step up over the next 12 to 24 months, said Pottinger’s Lake.Long-term decision making
“The challenge that all the big companies will have, and this is whether you are an investor or whether you are an operator that is investing your own capital, is dealing with how you make long-term decisions in when to invest in new capacity in the face of ongoing volatility and lots of uncertainty about the future,” he said. “So in practice, the decision-making can be quite reactive about what happens to prices, and the challenge is to be able to kind of cut through to what really is going to happen long term and when.” In terms of which commodity deal activity is likely to be focused on, PricewaterhouseCoopers expects there to remain a constant focus on gold. Gold, as O’Callaghan noted, has very different drivers around activity than other commodities. “The most critical one of which is: amongst all of the major commodities, it remains the most fragmented part of the sector from an ownership perspective,” he said. “There are very few dominants, and even the dominant players have recently pursued a merger of opportunity.” He said that despite a rebound in gold prices of late, the price of the commodity is still squeezing profit margins. “We believe that some of the midtiers and smaller tiers will look to merger opportunities as a means of survival, and for those that are under more significant threat because of their cost base, others may well see upside from them through productivity initiatives that the company is not in a position to be able put in place itself,” O’Callaghan said.Reluctant to show hand
In terms of where private capital buyers are likely to focus their investment funds, very little is known apart from their appetite for advanced, lower-risk assets. O’Callaghan said each mining-focused private capital fund has different drivers. “Some of them are set up as specialist funds in particular commodities, and they’re also not particularly keen to show their hand as to where they’re interested and not, even the really big guys,” he said. Ernst & Young’s Downham added that where a private capital fund chooses to invest will depend on its particular strategy, the experience of the people behind the fund and its historic relationship with the various commodities. “If you look at these funds they tend to be headed by individuals that have got a track record in the industry, and typically they’re most comfortable with a particular region or a particular type of deposit or indeed a particular strategy,” he said. “It could be a turnaround strategy; it could be a consolidation strategy; it could be some kind of carve-out strategy. …“So each one of them will play to those strengths rather than necessarily the sector as a whole looking to a particular strategic focus, be it commodity or market.”