South Africa’s export performance is dismal, mineral exports are declining and manufacturing remains stagnant and until these structural problems are overcome, South Africa will not grow and unemployment will remain unacceptably high, stated Director of Harvard’s Centre for International Development, Ricardo Hausmann.  

Speaking at a recent meeting hosted by the Centre for Development and Enterprise, Hausmann said that in ore to create the jobs that South Africa needs, significant expansion of export sectors must urgently take place.

“Unfortunately, South Africa’s export performance is dismal, said Professor Hausmann, who chaired the International Panel on the Accelerated and Shared Growth Initiative (ASGISA) that advised the South African government between 2004 and 2008 and a past Chair of the IMF-World Bank Development Committee.

Missed opportunities?

“Mineral beneficiation has long been considered by many in government and the ANC as the panacea for South Africa’s woes, but focussing on this relatively difficult to achieve economic outcome is unnecessarily costly while preventing policy makers from seeing other opportunities for economic development,” said Hausmann.

“To understand South Africa’s poor economic performance since the end of apartheid, and especially in the last decade, we must focus on key features that set the South African economy apart from many other, more successful countries. The very low levels of labour participation in South Africa are a good place to start.”

BEE flaws

Honing in on the black economic empowerment (BEE) policies of the country, Hausmann said there is too much emphasis in the policy framework on changing ownership, as opposed to creating jobs.

BEE is also impacting adversely on the creation of new firms, and thus preventing further job creation, according to Hausmann.

“In general, the country lacks agreement over what the vision for South Africa should be. More prosaically, and partly as a result, the various tiers of government and the private sector are not working towards a common goal or co-operating to achieve outcomes that will benefit the whole country.

“Finally, it is critical to alleviate South Africa’s skill constraints. The cheapest and most effective way to do that is to encourage skilled immigration. Unfortunately, recent immigration policy reform has made a bad situation even worse.”

Mining antipathy

There is a deeply rooted antipathy towards the mining sector within South Africa, owing to historical reasons, said Hausmann.

He says the country’s failure to take advantage of the commodity boom is killing the goose that lays the golden eggs.

By focusing on short-term redistribution in the mining sector, government policies are destroying long-term value.

“South Africans have been unable to agree on a growth-oriented strategy. I would have suggested giving workers 20% of the shares in the company they work in, so that they benefit from upswings in profits, or a similar type of arrangement that would lead to win-win outcomes. For complex reasons, such agreements have not been reached,” noted Hausmann.

Unemployment crisis

He says the unemployment crisis is the biggest policy challenge that South Africa confronts.

An employment rate of 60 per cent – roughly the global norm – would require 19 million jobs, nearly 50% more than the 13 million formal and informal jobs that exist today.

Hausmann says that statistics reinforce the view that directly or indirectly, unemployment is at the root of all of South Africa’s most serious social, economic and political challenges.

In his concluding remarks, Hausmann said South Africa needs skills, and it needs a clear strategy, co-ordinated across many sectors of the state and the economy, to change the structure of the economy.

“Only then will the country grow and create the jobs that will reduce inequality, eradicate poverty and allow the country to fulfil the massive promise that my colleagues and I encountered when we first came here in 2004.”

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy