In an unprecedented step‚ practising advocates of the Johannesburg Bar were on Friday allowed to present a statement in the landmark silicosis case in the High Court in Johannesburg about a controversial statement made by one of the attorneys.

The advocates also took the opportunity to make remarks about the racially and gender-skewed briefing patterns in the sector. Richard Spoor‚ an attorney representing some of the mineworkers in the certification application‚ last week made comments in a Facebook post responding to remarks about the lack of black advocates in the team that he briefed.

Spoor said his team of advocates was all-white because his firm briefed advocates willing to work for a reduced rate and it was an exceptional team. He also said the kind of work he did had no room for charity or experimentation.

Spoor apologised last weekend. All nine advocates representing the mineworkers are white and there are only two black advocates among the six legal teams representing the gold mining companies that are opposing the certification of the class action.

The court on Friday reserved judgement in the application by former mineworkers who seek to certify a class action of mineworkers who suffered from silicosis and tuberculosis (TB) as a result of exposure to silica dust at the mines. The mineworkers want damages against 32 companies that owned or operated 82 gold mines from 1965 until December 31 2012.

The application ran for 10 days.

Johannesburg Bar Council chairman Dali Mpofu read a statement which had been signed by 115 advocates in which they deplored “the racist sting” of the statement by Spoor. They said Spoor’s statement implied that black advocates were incompetent‚ unintelligent and greedy‚ and were not suitable or interested in public interest cases.

“We reject these blanket and unwarranted attacks on us and other black colleagues as untrue and motivated by the kind of racial bigotry and prejudice which is inimical to and in gross violation of the spirit and letter of our democratic constitution‚” the statement read.

The advocates also endorsed another statement issued by the Johannesburg Bar Council on Wednesday‚ which said that the failure of the legal teams to involve black and women counsel was an embarrassment to the profession.

The Bar Council said efforts to change discriminatory briefing patterns in the past 21 years had yielded very insufficient result. Geoff Budlender SC‚ advocate for the mineworkers‚ said the statement by Spoor was truly offensive and unacceptable. He also said counsel briefed by Spoor had dissociated themselves from his statement. All the advocates for the mining companies who addressed the court shared the same sentiments about Spoor’s statement.

Chris Loxton SC‚ for Harmony Gold‚ said briefing patterns were a persistent and a real problem.

Johannesburg Deputy Judge President Phineas Mojapelo said the court would not in its judgment deal with the statement or the responses by advocates‚ but that did not mean the court was not aware of the debate and concerns about briefing patterns.

TMG Courts and Law

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy