A landmark South African court case that starts Tuesday will ask a judge to rule whether the need to reduce racial inequality trumps shareholder rights.
The Chamber of Mines of South Africa is asking the High Court to back its view that the Mining Charter stipulates that companies should be credited with disposing of a minimum of 26% of their assets to black investors even if those stakes were later sold. The original charter agreed to by the government and the mining industry took effect in 2004. The Department of Mineral Resources updated it in 2010 to make the minimum requirement permanent. “It is going to be huge — if the chamber loses, everybody who’s been disempowered will have to be re-empowered,” Andrew Mitchell, a partner at the Johannesburg-based legal firm Fasken Martineau LLP, said by phone. “The shareholders are not going to like it because it means they’ll get rediluted again.”South Africa’s push for increased black ownership of the mining industry, which accounts for almost half of the country’s exports, is part of an effort to address the legacy of apartheid that locked the black majority out of key industries. The charter also sets targets for companies to boost the numbers of black people in management and improve training and benefits for communities near mines. No black South Africans lead the country’s eight biggest precious-metal companies, all of which are headquartered locally.
The industry remains “dominated by white males,” the mines department said last year.
Black ControlWhile the chamber says black control in mining averaged 38 percent by the end of 2014, the government maintains just 20 percent of companies had complied with the minimum requirement. The two parties used different criteria.
The chamber plans to argue that the mines ministry breached the charter by making the 26 percent requirement permanent, and if the government’s arguments are upheld, it could have “devastating” economic and reputational consequences for the companies, the court documents show. The group declined to comment on questions submitted by Bloomberg.
The chamber’s members include Anglo American Platinum Ltd., the world’s biggest platinum producer, South32 Ltd., AngloGold Ashanti Ltd. and Glencore Plc. South Africa is the world’s biggest source of platinum and manganese and the continent’s largest gold and coal producer. It also produces iron ore, vanadium and chrome. Measurement CriteriaThe chamber says that while its members would’ve met or exceeded the 26 percent shareholding target if all their black economic empowerment, known as BEE, deals worth 205 billion rand ($13.5 billion) since 2000 counted, a quarter could miss the required threshold if sold-down stakes are disregarded. Companies that may fall short of meeting these conditions include Anglo American Platinum and Sibanye Gold Ltd., the largest producer of the metal from South African mines, the Johannesburg-based chamber said in a letter to the mineral resources department that was included in the court papers.