pl244632-long_steel_u_channel_of_s275jr_gb700_q235b_q345b_jis_mild_steel_products_productArcelorMittal South Africa’s (AMSA) R1.5 billion fine for price fixing sends a strong message of deterrence and is an important milestone in the commission’s enforcement against cartels, Commissioner Tembinkosi Bonakele said on Monday.

On Monday, it was announced that all investigations and prosecutions relating to a settlement agreement between AMSA and the Competition Commission have been finalised and AMSA will pay an administrative penalty of R1.5 billion for price fixing. They have agreed to pay the penalty over five years as from 2017 at installments of no less than R300 million per annum, the commission said on Monday.

“The commission is delighted to bring an end to these longstanding proceedings,” said Bonakele.

“In addition, the pricing remedy reflects our desire to protect South African consumers against dominant firms, particularly on key industrial products. This remedy is a safeguard in the event that AMSA were to revert to the historical prices that the commission regards as excessive.”

The agreement relates to various cases the commission investigated, some relating to complaints dating as far back as 1999. Some complaints were subsequently referred to the tribunal for adjudication.

AMSA admitted guilt to only two of  the six matters – the long steel matter; which relates to allegations of fixing prices, allocating customers and sharing commercially sensitive information, and (admitted to being) a consumer of scrap in relation to the scrap metal allegation of price fixing.

Long steel matter

A 2008 investigation against long and flat steel producers in SA, including AMSA, included a raid on premises of a number of steel producers.

The commission’s investigation found that AMSA and some of its competitors in the manufacturing of long steel products, engaged in collusion by fixing prices and discounts, allocating customers and sharing commercially sensitive information through the South African Iron and Steel Institute (SAISI) and the SA Reinforced Concrete Engineers’ Association.

Scrap metal

A 2009 investigation against a number of consumers of scrap, including AMSA, for collusive practices, found they fixed the purchase price of scrap metal by collectively negotiating and agreeing a standard formula which was used to determine the purchase price of scrap metal as a buyers’ cartel.

In August 2013, the Commission referred this matter to the Tribunal for adjudication.

 

-Fin24

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy