Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Mineral Resources has passed a report on its view of reservations expressed by President Jacob Zuma on the new mining bill, the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act (MPRDA).
While accepting and making slight adjustments to the bill based on two of the President’s reservations concerning procedural issues, it has rejected two key reservations relating to the substance of the bill.
An impasse over the unconstitutionality of the two substantive issues raised by the President – a position shared by the DA – may result in the President refusing to assent to the Bill. He then may use Section 79(4)(b) of the Constitution to refer the bill to the Constitutional Court.
The DA had written to Zuma suggesting the Bill was unconstitutional. Some of those reasons were cited by Zuma when he sent the Bill back to Parliament nearly 18 months ago.
Since then the Bill has been in limbo with apparent confusion or disagreement in the ANC about processes that should be followed to have the Bill corrected.
At issue was a suggestion by Zuma that it would be unconstitutional to elevate the Mining Charter to the status of legislation without subjecting the Charter to the same requirement of parliamentary agreement before changes were made. As it stands, the Minister will be allowed to change the Charter without consultation with the legislature.
The second substantive issue concerned whether the designation of strategic minerals and the restrictions on exports would contravene South Africa’s international trade obligations. Zuma’s view was that it would, the ANC members of the committee thought it would not.
Bills are not sent back to Parliament lightly. The effective 50% mark given by the committee to the President’s views is a political embarrassment to President Zuma, and reveals divisions in the ANC’s views on mining.
The DA believes the MPRDA is a deeply flawed bill, which will damage the mining industry. If the President were to assent to the Bill, they believe it will remain vulnerable to a Constitutional Court challenge, and this will result in continued uncertainty surrounding South Africa’s mining law.
-AllAfrica