glenoptiGlencore and Eskom have clashed heads since the publishing of the former Public Protector’s State of Capture Report, with both parties denying the others version of events.

Glencore rejected Eskom’s claims that its Optimum Coal Mine sold coal at high prices and said it had negotiated in good faith for over two years with Eskom.

It went on to accuse Eskom of lying about Optimum wanting to raise coal prices and denied it had proposed a coal price of more than R300 per tonne for Hendrina Power Station.

In a media statement sent on 6 November 2016, Eskom expressed that Glencore vehemently denying that it had ever proposed coal price increases of more than R300 per tonne to the electricity parastatal, could not go unchallenged.

“It is unfortunate that Glencore has suggested that Eskom has lied about Optimum Coal Mine wanting to increase the coal prices to R570 per tonne,” the company said in the statement.

 

First letter to Eskom from Optimum

Eskom produced a letter dated 30 June 2015, where Optimum said, “The base price for the first period and second period shall be escalated on each anniversary of the base date in accordance with a price adjustment factor which is to be calculated in accordance with an escalation table to be agreed between Eskom and Optimum.”

In terms of the proposed deal, the coal supply agreement to Hendrina would be renegotiated at R300 per tonne until 2018, and thereafter be extended to 2023 at R570 per tonne, Eskom said.

Eskom said Optimum had failed to renegotiate and extend the coal supply agreement for Hendrina at prices higher than the R150 per tonne contractual agreement, but Optimum later proposed a “compromise deal”.

Glencore’s Optimum denied this stating that they were supplying Eskom at well below cost of production, and that its last offer was R300 per tonne and not R570 per tonne as was claimed.

The commodity trading and mining group say Eskom rejected their offer and terminated negotiations.

The power utility later awarded the contract to Gupta owned mining company Tegeta, maintaining that their focus was on coal costs, and not mine ownership.

 

Confusion of actual figure

There also seems to be confusion between the figures, Shamiela Letsoalo, Head of Communications, Glencore, quotes the figure at R 530 per tonne in an email, while the letter produced by Eskom allegedly from Optimum, quotes the figure to be R570.

 

Second letter to Eskom from Optimum

In another letter dated 17 September 2015, when Optimum was under business rescue, they proposed a price increase to R630 per tonne and a coal supply agreement extension until 2023.

In that letter, the business rescue practitioners proposed a coal price increase of R443 per tonne with effect from 1 October 2015 to 31 December 2018. Thereafter the price would increase to R630 per tonne until 2023.

Eskom said in the statement they were not involved in the sale agreement between Glencore and Tegeta. All they were interested in was ensuring that the new owners were aware that the coal prices, volumes and quality would not be renegotiated or compromised, and that the penalties imposed on Optimum would not be waivered.

 

 

 

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy