Hogan LovellsAccording to the global law firm Hogan Lovells, there has been criticism aimed at the application of the instructions issued in terms of Section 54(1)(a) of the Mine Health and Safety Act (MHSA).

The criticism comes after an inspector conducted an inspection on Level 44 of Section 12 of AngloGold Ashanti’s Kopanang Mine, because of infractions related to tramming and the storage of explosives.

Though the inspection, when conducted, was limited to a small part of the overall operations at the mine, closure was implemented throughout the entire mine from 17 October, at a significant loss to the mine.

A labour court judge found that the blanket stoppage that unjustifiably halted operations at Kopanang mine because of these infractions  was disproportionate and should have been applied to just that area of the operation instead of implementing the closure throughout the whole mine.

According to Warren Beech, partner and head of mining, Hogan Lovells, and Wessel Badenhorst, partner, Hogan Lovells, the act has had a positive impact on health and safety at mines at the detriment of production, because of the disruptions that the Section 54 instructions cause.

“The instructions in terms of Section 54(1)(a) of the MHSA stop entire operations at a mine, rather than focusing on a particular workplace, where an occurrence, practice or condition endangers or may endanger the health and safety of persons in that workplace,” writes Beech and Badenhorst in an article.

Beech and Badenhorst believe that isolated closures may be better suited, in particular circumstances, to achieving the objective of improved health and safety, rather than complete stoppages.

Labour Court interference limits powers of state?

Further criticism of the implementation of the legislature has been levelled against the lack of guidelines relating to the circumstances under which Section 54 Instructions may be issued and, if issued, in relation to the scope – being the whole or a part of a mine

The law firm highlights the inconsistent execution of the legislation by inspectors, thus making it extremely difficult for the stakeholders at the mines to efficiently and proactively address and engage with the MHSI in the circumstances where the MHSI intends to, or actually issues a Section 54 Instruction.

The South African Chamber of Mines said that a Labour Court decision overturning a government-imposed safety stoppage at the AngloGold Ashanti mine placed limits on the power of state inspectors.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy