Department-of-Minerals-ResourcesThe Department of Mineral Resources (DMR)  has once again suffered legal defeat, after a case was brought against them by Aquila Steel South Africa.

The case follows last year’s Labour Court judgment, where the DMR was found to have ignored the notion of ‘proportionality’ in its shutting down of AngloGold Ashanti’s Kopanang mine.

Common to both of these cases, is the inappropriate application of the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act (MPRDA), that is applied without careful consideration by the DMR, when addressing applications for rights under the provisions of the legislation.

The Aquila judgment is particularly significant in that the court was highly critical of the DMR, finding that the DMR had acted irrationally, incompetently, and had obstructed the very thing that it was meant to facilitate under the provisions of the MPRDA, namely investment in the South African mining industry.

Rising tensions

Ziza Limited, incorporated in 1893, which was owned by the Zimbabwean and the Zambian governments, applied for a prospecting right in 2005. The company was granted the prospecting right based on the fact that it held an unused old order right.

The application was accepted and the prospecting right was granted, and registered in the name of Pan African Mineral Development Company Proprietary Limited (PAMDC), despite PAMDC not being the applicant for a prospecting right, and in the absence of any application to transfer the prospecting right from Ziza to PAMDC.

Ziza did not, once the prospecting right was granted, attempt to carry out prospecting activities, nor did they demonstrate that it had the necessary financial resources or the technical ability to do so.

Almost a year after the Ziza application was submitted, Aquila submitted an application for a prospecting right.

The DMR later executed a prospecting right in favour of Aquila, and the prospecting right was granted, however, there was an overlap between the properties which formed the subject of the Ziza Prospecting Right, and the Aquila Prospecting Right.

So the court was essentially tasked with determining who had the valid or the better rights. The court had to look specifically at the queuing system which the MPRDA allows for – where first come, is first served, and whether the legislature was complied with, in an appropriate manner.

Key findings of the court

In the matter between Aquila Steel Limited, and the DMR, the circumstances giving rise to the review application brought by Aquila included lengthy delays in relation to applications for prospecting and mining rights, inadequate communications between concerned parties and the DMR, double-granting of rights, lengthy delays in relation to internal appeals in terms of Section 96 of the MPRDA and misinterpretation of the provisions of the MPRDA.

The court found that the decision of the DMR to accept the Ziza application was “irrational and resulted in a sequence of events which led to the present dispute”

The ruling was made in favour of  Aquila Steel, where the High Court went so far as to overrule the Minister’s decision on prospecting and mining rights and instead award these rights to Aquila. This appears to have been influenced, substantially, by what the court described as the ‘tardiness’ of the DMR.

Additional Reading?

Request Free Copy