The High Court of Singapore has set aside an arbitral award issued to Swissbourgh Diamond Mines and South African investors who claim their mining leases had been expropriated by the Kingdom of Lesotho.
However, the SADC Tribunal could not hear the claims as it was dissolved and ultimately replaced in 2014 by a new SADC Tribunal whose jurisdiction did not extend to such disputes. It was acknowledged that this left a “legal vacuum” for pending cases.
Each member state was left to decide on an alternative forum for resolution of such cases, however, Lesotho did not do this and declined the claimants’ invitation for the claim to be resolved by arbitration before the PCA. Judge Ramesh concluded that the investors’ right to submit disputes to the original SADC tribunal, which had been contained within an investment protocol signed by the SADC, did not amount to an “investment” as defined in that agreement. That meant that the PCA tribunal would have wrongly assumed jurisdiction over the dispute. Therefore he set the award aside in its entirety. “As I observed earlier, investment treaties are fine-tuned to balance the interests of host states and investors, and it would be ultimately counteractive to a treaty’s objective and purpose to extend its protections to situations clearly beyond its contemplation,” the judge said in the opinion. “While the defendants are understandably disappointed with the turn their investment has taken, that cannot be cured by doing violence to a dispute resolution provision in the treaty.” The judge noted in the opinion that this is the first case in Singapore in which a party sought to set aside an investor-state arbitral award on the merits. Read more about the case background …