The Mpumalanga MEC for Agriculture, Rural Development and Land and Environmental Affairs, Vusi Shongwe, has refused the appeal by eight civil society and community organisations against the environmental approval granted to Indian-owned Atha-Africa Ventures Pty Ltd to build a coal mine inside a protected area and a strategic water source area near Wakkerstroom in Mpumalanga.
Against this background, it is worth noting that Atha has provided a financial guarantee for closure costs of only R5.758 million – inadequate for a coal mine in any environment, but particularly so in a sensitive environment,” said CER.
The environmental health group, noted that the MEC said the mine was in line with South Africa’s invitation to Indian companies to invest in South Africa’s mining sector, and that the mine would help to “develop export markets for South African products and services.” However, many experts conclude that coal demand has peaked and that any further investment in coal assets now risks stranded assets and also risks other supply viability as over-supply will drive down prices. The MEC also assumed in his decision that impoverished local communities would benefit from the mine. Unfortunately, what the MEC did not take into account is that Atha’s own reports give no guarantee that jobs would be sourced locally. Instead, it states that “there is unlikely to be significant opportunities for the local population to be employed during the construction phase, and the opportunities are likely to be temporary” and there will be “limited numbers of unskilled, [and] semi-skilled employment opportunities.” Atha was granted a mining right by the Minister of Mineral Resources in 2015, shortly after the declaration of the Mabola Protected Environment by the Mpumalanga MEC. Since then, Atha has received licences and approvals from the Mpumalanga environment department, the Department of Water & Sanitation, and the Ministers of Environmental Affairs and Mineral Resources. All these approvals have been challenged. The coalition consists of the Mining and Environmental Justice Community Network of South Africa, Earthlife Africa Johannesburg, Birdlife South Africa, the Endangered Wildlife Trust, Federation for a Sustainable Environment, groundWork, Association for Water and Rural Development (AWARD) and the Bench Marks Foundation, and is represented by the Centre for Environmental Rights.