The Brazilian Appeals Court found partially in Vale’s favour in a $10 billion legal dispute with government over taxation of the miner’s foreign operations.
Last week’s ruling follows a decade-long battle by a number of Brazilian companies against the government’s tax laws. Vale and other companies including Brazilian steelmaker Gerdau SA and brewer Companhia de Bebidas das Americas (AmBev) claim that despite their paying of taxes in foreign territories, the Brazilian government is assessing tax on these subsidiaries, effectively amounting to double taxation. Brazil’s Superior Justice Tribunal ruled that due to the country’s treaties with Belgium, Luxembourg and Denmark, it couldn’t tax Vale’s profits from units in those countries. However, the court also ruled that the Brazilian government’s taxation of Vale’s profits in Bermuda were valid, because Brazil had no relevant tax treaty with the island. It is uncertain how this will affect a $10 billion settlement deal Vale signed with the government in November last year, in which it agreed to pay a discounted sum for profits it had made from foreign units between 2003 and 2012.This was part of a settlement programme offered by government after Congress passed legislation that scrapped or reduced fines, interest and legal charges if companies chose to settle their claims in single payments or instalments.
Vale also agreed to end lawsuits involving the collection of taxes on foreign units between 2003 and 2012, and accepted not to receive any rebate for these. At the time, Vale took the deal to decrease risk and provide greater predictability regarding the outcomes and costs of ongoing legal battles. However, Vale CEO Murilo Ferreira said in a conference call following the deal that it still disagreed with government’s taxation laws, and that if other parties’ legal applications were successful in court, the company could still demand compensation. “We will discuss whether we will ask for money back from payments we already made, if we are going to ask to suspend instalments payments,” Vale’s tax affairs director Octavio Bulcao said after the ruling, as quoted by Bloomberg. Meanwhile, Brazil’s finance ministry plans to appeal the ruling, and says the court finding will not have any impact on the $10 billion settlement agreement signed in November. The ministry said in a statement that the terms of the agreement see Vale permanently giving up the right to reduce or receive any rebate for related assessments for the 2003-2012 period.